School officials think that cellphones cause anxiety, depression and distractions to learning. I see their point, but I would like to offer the opinion that there are other stressors in the lives of students in school and out of school. The decision for this 2024- 2025 school year that students shouldn’t have their phones in class or in the hallways during class time came as a surprise to students and was a disappointment to many.
Many disagree with this matter, including myself. In cases where there are safety issues in the building, having a phone can help students feel connected to their families in the event of an emergency. But needing to see better safety and more protection is one of our biggest concerns and there should be attention by teachers and administrators on that as much as keeping phones away.
Students with extenuating circumstances in their families may want to keep their phones on them to keep contact with their loved ones. Also, being able to focus for some students is a factor to consider, since phones can provide music for those who need to concentrate on assignments when possible. Listening to music can help students who worry or need to calm down.
I get that phones can be a distraction for some students, I’ve seen it, and I understand both sides between students and teachers/administrators. However, when thinking about the school environment, locked doors, cameras, and walkie talkies aren’t doing anything if we keep having dangerous situations occur. When phones are not accessible to students due to being taken and locked up, this creates a feeling of helplessness. Phones are a safety net for many and are helpful when there are chaotic situations that come up.